As noted in the previous post, I was minutes away from seeing the new Batman flick from Director Johnathon Nolan.
And Eckhart did indeed turn in a good performance as "Harvey Dent/Two-Face". However, he was nowhere close to Ledger's take on "The Joker."
Ledger was known to be a
method actor, ala: Robert DeNiro. These actors/actresses essentially become the character they are playing at the time.
I think it's fair to say that while Ledger clearly had emotional issues due to the break-up of his marriage with Michelle Williams (whom he met during the filming of "Brokeback Mountain") and was taking some medication to deal with those issues, I think this role ended up killing him.
"The Joker" is such a dastardly, devilish, psychotic character that required Ledger to go to such a dark place that he was unable to overcome the demons, and this role may have solidified and exacerbated his demons.
On the surface, Ledger's portrayal of "The Joker" seems almost too easy to do. I think it's easy for people to watch the movie and con themselves into thinking, "I could do that." Eckhart, in "Dent," does indeed make a much bigger character transition during the movie, and it's easier to see why his role took a lot to do.
But, it is Ledger; this movie is all Ledger. Without Ledger this movie is nothing, without Eckhart's character, the movie still stands on it's own.
Ledger didn't overplay his hand. He struck the right balance between being the certifiably-crazy man "The Joker" is, but Ledger also gave him a sense of his own humanity. Whereas, Jack Nicholson, who played the same role in the original "Batman" flick, portrayed him to be a simple mad man who wanted to just have some fun with no real sense of the man that was.
I'm not Batman purist as I noted I'd never read the comic, but while I liked the original "Batman" and Nicholson's portrayal, I think the darker portrayal by Ledger is more compelling, and makes a better story.
Ledger deserves the Emmy nod he will assuredly get, and it will be hard to beat his performance in this movie.
I give it: 4 out of 5 stars.